Where syphilis came from: the oldest argument in infectious disease
Last reviewed November 16, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.
Few questions in medical history have been argued over as long as this one. Syphilis exploded across Europe in the 1490s, immediately after Columbus's first voyages returned, and people have been debating the connection ever since.
For centuries it was a fight between bones and documents. In the last few years, ancient DNA has started to settle it.
Related pages: Syphilis
The bottom line
- Syphilis belongs to a family of related bacteria that also cause yaws, bejel and pinta, differing by a tiny fraction of their genomes.
- Treponemal diseases were present in the Americas thousands of years before Columbus. Ancient DNA has been recovered from 2,000-year-old remains in Brazil.
- A 2024 analysis of five ancient American genomes concluded that the whole T. pallidum family originated in the Americas.
- Whether sexually transmitted syphilis specifically arose there, or evolved from a non-sexually transmitted relative after contact.
- What the treponemal lesions found in some older European and Eurasian bones actually represent.
The story, step by step
- 1. The family ()
- 2. The old debate (Historians, palaeopathologists and physicians, for 500 years)
- 3. 2024: Brazil (Majander, Schuenemann and colleagues, 2024)
- 4. The answer so far (A separate international team, published in Nature in December 2024)
Four diseases, almost one organism
What happens
Syphilis is one of four human treponemal diseases, caused by bacteria so similar they are classed as subspecies.
What the research shows
- Syphilis (T. pallidum subspecies pallidum) is sexually transmitted and systemic.
- Yaws (subspecies pertenue) and bejel (subspecies endemicum) spread by skin and mouth contact, usually in childhood, in warm climates.
- Pinta affects the skin only.
- Their genomes differ by only about 0.03%, which is why distinguishing them in ancient remains is so hard.
Why it matters
The question isn't only where syphilis came from, but how one branch of a skin-contact family became a sexually transmitted systemic disease.
What's still uncertain
- Blood tests cannot reliably tell these diseases apart, which complicates research in places where yaws still exists.
Read more
Next: The old debate
Columbian versus pre-Columbian
What happens
Two positions have been argued since the 1500s.
What the research shows
- The Columbian hypothesis: syphilis came from the Americas and was carried back by Columbus's crews, explaining the explosive European epidemic from 1495.
- The pre-Columbian hypothesis: it was already present in Europe, previously confused with leprosy and other diseases, and something changed to make it suddenly recognizable.
- The pre-Columbian side rested on bone lesions in older European skeletons that look treponemal.
- The Columbian side rested on the documentary record: a disease that European physicians described as entirely new, arriving at a specific moment.
Why it matters
This was stuck for centuries because bone lesions can be ambiguous and documents can be misread. Neither side could win on its own evidence.
What's still uncertain
- Dating skeletal remains has its own difficulties, including the reservoir effect in people who ate a lot of seafood.
Read more
Next: 2024: Brazil
Two-thousand-year-old DNA from Brazilian remains
What happens
Researchers recovered treponemal DNA from human remains in Brazil and reconstructed four ancient genomes.
What the research shows
- The remains were about 2,000 years old, the oldest verified treponemal DNA found at that point.
- The genomes were most closely related to the bacterium that causes bejel, a non-sexually transmitted relative.
- This placed treponemal disease in the Americas more than a thousand years before Columbus.
- Because the strains were endemic rather than sexually transmitted types, the finding complicated the simple story as much as it supported it.
Why it matters
It proved these organisms were circulating in the Americas long before contact, but not yet that sexually transmitted syphilis specifically came from there.
What's still uncertain
- Treponemal DNA survives poorly in bone, so samples are rare and hard-won.
Read more
- Majander 2024, NatureJournal
- University of Basel summaryUniversity
Next: The answer so far
An American origin for the whole family
What happens
Researchers analyzed five ancient treponemal genomes from before and around the time of European contact, from Mexico, Chile, Argentina and Peru.
What the research shows
- The genomes represented ancient relatives of all three lineages: syphilis, yaws and bejel.
- They showed diversity that had not been seen before, and an emergence of T. pallidum that post-dates humans arriving in the Americas.
- The authors concluded the results support an American origin for all T. pallidum characterized at the genomic level.
- Reporting on the work noted the epidemic then moved thousands of kilometres in a few years, carried by returning ships.
Why it matters
On the genetic evidence as it stands, the Columbian side of a 500-year argument has the stronger case, though the picture is more complicated than the old story.
What's still uncertain
- Conclusions rest on a small number of recoverable genomes.
- This does not explain what the treponemal-looking lesions in some older European bones were, and that question remains open.
- Ancient DNA findings in this field have overturned expectations more than once, and could again.